Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Just when I thought I was out, they drag me back in.

A lot of people have been bugging me to hear my thoughts on the whole "Allah" thing. Which is both flattering and kinda weird, but okay. So here goes: I don't really care either way.

Oh, don't get me wrong, I think firebombing churches are stupid and very close to being acts of terrorism when you think about it. (If you're a Muslim in the West and you're throwing Molotov cocktails at churches, then it will be terrorism. Trust me on this.) Actually, okay, this is the part about the controversy that I genuinely care about: I desperately wish we Muslims could protest over something we don't like and not look like insane people. Is that too much to ask?

But use it, don't use it, who gives a shit, really. Yes, a lot of people, including those whose opinions I usually respect and really should know better, like to say that it's a conspiracy to confuse young Muslims or whatever. Which is fucking retarded, because there are already laws against converting Muslims in this country.

There's the sense of ownership issue, in which "Allah" belongs to Muslims and nowhere else. Except for all the historical evidence that suggests that the word "Allah" actually predates Islam. Except that technically it's not the same Allah. It's complicated.

All of which is utterly pointless and I really could not care less. Except that I've already written 200-plus words and counting, so, er, I guess I do on some level. But anyway. Use "Allah", don't use it. What do I care?

Though I do find it amusing that so many people are suddenly caring about the issue and saying that they should have the right to use the word "Allah", when no one cared until now. Tell people they can't do something, they'll scream at the top of their lungs for their right to do it. Look at me for example. I didn't want to write about this at all, until my mom pointed a finger at me and warned me not to write about it. So I sure showed her!

(I'm so, so sorry, Ma.)

And another thing that annoys me about this: it puts me in a position to agree with Mahathir. International press hasn't been kind to Malaysia over this issue, and they shouldn't be. But Switzerland bans minarets and no one so much as shook a fist in outrage. As a Muslim, that annoys me. Though Mahathir naturally avoids the subject of people firebombing churches. Which is a pretty Mahathir thing to do, actually. Something bad happens in Malaysia, wag your finger at the West, then ignore the problem completely.

But a dialogue probably needs to be done. There's an extreme disconnect, I'm noticing, between Muslims and non-Muslims over this issue. (All anecdotal evidence with no scientific merit, of course.) I hate to say this, but while Muslims can certainly try to chill a little bit and not get all outrage-y all the time, I don't think non-Muslims are doing enough to understand Malay Muslims. To them it's just a word. To a lot of Malays, it's so much more than that.

(523 words. I must really not care about this.)

3 comments:

Zai said...

welcome back slut

Rie said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Rie said...

hahaha...you sure showed your mama how 'not' to tell you not to write about something.

I'll echo Zai's welcome back (minus the calling you slut, tho it does beg the question of what you've been doing with your fine self eh??? teehee)

2 comments (or p'haps more, if broken down):
Re the swiss minaret thing, not no one shook a fist.
Sure I'm linking to some tame BBC article here (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8385893.stm), but dude, even THE VATICAN shook a finger.
In this other article (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/nov/30/switzerland-ban-minarets-reaction-islam) -- I find the words of the OIC dude apt to our A-word situation --- "The main thing is to keep calm and to realise how much work still needs to be done to defend basic freedoms," said Ba, the OIC ambassador in Geneva."We must do this by taking a constructive part in the debate on all issues which cause fear and concern, and to try to bring people together in order to confront extremism."


OH OH OH! I actually just read the article you linked to re Dr M. UHM! DUDE. Ok, f'give me if you were being ironic and I just totally didn't get it when you said that you are in a position to agree with him, but woi! "The outspoken former prime minister, whose administration in 1986 restricted usage of the term and other Arabic words exclusive to Islam, pointed out that if Malaysia should blamed as undemocratic then Switzerland and France has to be placed in the same category as well."

the swiss minaret ban was based a REFERENDUM. How much more democratic can you get (imho, not necessary the most just means of decision making, BUT the most democratic, pretty much yes). It was VOTED upon. not imposed by some ban by the Home Ministry under the pretext of some damn fool 'reason'. That's like comparing apples and oranges and saying both are fruits that grow on trees and therefore.... o_O


I know, I know, feel free to go haiyoh Marie, go write your own blogpost, but humour me, one more comment re your closing lines: "I don't think non-Muslims are doing enough to understand Malay Muslims. To them it's just a word. To a lot of Malays, it's so much more than that." (emphasis mine) --- no it's not just a word, friend. To BM speaking practicing Christians (Catholics or otherwise) that *is* their appelation for God. The Almighty. It's not "just a word" to them. Good God, it's most certainly not just a word. Perhaps it is for those of us who don't speak BM and have no need to use the word Allah, but for those who have only ever known and called Allah by that name only...that's pretty major. BUT, I think we're going down the scary slippery slope when we even acknowledge the "it means more to me therefore I own it" reasoning/line of argument --- which eclipses the larger issue at hand about the freedom of speech (in Malaysia), and the claim to 'owning' a word. Once a precedent is set....esp one based on silly logic, we're all pretty much f*cked, kan?!

I guess I'm one of those who does care -- hence this response (which you are absolutely not obliged to respond to in return - given your loud and clear stand that you don't really care either way... I rezzpekk that) ---

erm. yeah. so ok-lah. sekian, bye-bye. xox